Masons, Mobsters, and Spooks, O My! A Field Guide to Bob Dylan’s “Murder Most Foul”

Image for post
Image for post

Callow Youth of America: So, why all the noise about “Murder Most Foul”?

The Wise Old Owl: Outside of it being we’re talking about — The Big Bubba of Rebellion, High Priest of Protest, the Czar of Dissent, the Duke of Disobedience, Leader of the Freeloaders, Kaiser of Apostasy, Archbishop of Anarchy, the Big Cheese — “Murder Most Foul” is the first original song he’s released since 2012.

at 16 minutes 56 seconds, it’s also the longest song he’s ever released.

it’s his first-ever #1 Song on a Billboard Chart.

, it’s got all sort of things in it to push Boomer buttons.

CYA: Heh, “Boomer buttons.” It’s about the Kennedy assassination back in the Sixties, right? And that’s a big deal to Boomers?

WOO: Yeah, some would say it was a pivotal point in American history — equivalent to what we’re going through now with the pandemic. It’s one of those moments in time where everything changes from what it was to something new and there’s no going back to how things were.

CYA: Really? I mean he was the President and all, but one man dying changed all of history?

WOO: It wouldn’t be the first time that one man’s death changed the course of history. With the assassination unmade, it goes something like this…

Image for post
Image for post
An alt-Universe JFK in his 60s.

Kennedy isn’t assassinated, and we don’t get trapped in the Vietnam quagmire. No Vietnam War and there’s no Youth Movement, or at least not at the level of mass protests, Hippies and the Woodstock Generation. The core of the so-called Movement was resistance to the Draft. Once Nixon ended the draft and got us out of Vietnam — his “Peace with Honor” a decade after Kennedy died — the Movement pretty much splintered into different factions and faded.

No Youth Movement, no fracturing of America, at least not at the level that we experienced in the `60s and the `70s, and has reached its apogee in these modern times.

Maybe, maybe, maybe. And yeah, it’s looking at history with rose-colored glasses and “What If” nostalgia, but it doesn’t make the feeling any less real. Who knows? Maybe things would have been worse if Kennedy had lived. Maybe we’d be in exactly the same spot that we’re in today. The point is that there’s a feeling shared by many of the Boomer generation that things started sliding sideways in America with Kennedy’s assassination.

CYA: Gotcha. I think Stephen King did a book and movie about that. The song makes it sound like Dylan thinks some sort of conspiracy was behind Kennedy’s assassination.

WOO: Who knows what Bob Dylan thinks? I think the more important thing is that the of “Murder Most Foul” thinks a conspiracy brought down Kennedy.

CYA: And that’s when the song gets a little random for me. does think killed Kennedy?

Image for post
Image for post
Masonic Square and Compasses.

WOO: It’s never made clear. There’s references to the Mob and to the CIA. Maybe the Mafia and the Agency killed Kennedy together. Maybe it was anti-Castro Cuban exiles. Maybe Freemasons.

CYA: Wait, Masons? My Grand-dad is a Mason; they do charity stuff. Why would Dylan — sorry, the narrator — think Masons had anything to do with it?

WOO: Okay, take a deep breath, and fasten your seatbelt. It’s going to be a bumpy ride…

There’s several “Kennedy assassination instigated by Freemasons” theories. The one alluded to in “Murder Most Foul” seems to be based on a 1987 essay titled “33°” The author — a James Shelby Downard — was well-known in conspiracy circles for his theories that occultism was behind many 20th century historical events, including the Kennedy assassination.

CYA: Wait, is a song by Marilyn Manson!

WOO: Yeah, it looks like Bob Dylan isn’t the only musician interested in Masonic symbolism.

°the essayposits that Freemasons were responsible for Kennedy’s death through an occult ritual which Downard terms the “Killing of the King,” and is related to an allegory on the certainty of death presented to candidates aspiring to the Third Degree of Freemasonry.

Downard is a bit vague on the “ ?” of the Killing of the King ritual, but apparently Kennedy’s assassination had something to do with Freemason astronauts… Downard writes.

Ah, yes, yes — Freemasons on the Moon. Makes perfect sense, and when the facts don’t quite fit —Downard confuses a Biblical king with a Master Mason having the same name and it’s actually the “Knight of the Sun” degree — Downard ain’t shy about tweaking those facts.

Interlude — Freemasons on the Moon

Image for post
Image for post
The Thirty-third Degree Scottish Rite Flag That Went to the Moon on Apollo XI in 1969, carried by “Buzz” Aldrin

When I wrote that sarcastic line above, I didn’t realize that Freemasons reached the Moon and brought a, ahem, with them. In fact, Freemasonry opened a branch of the Grand Lodge of Texas on the Moon and established Masonic Territorial Jurisdiction there thanks to the efforts of astronaut and Freemason Brother Edwin E. “Buzz” Aldrin, Jr.

relates the Tranquility Lodge 2000 webpage,

Image for post
Image for post
Emblem of Tranquility Lodge 2000

Tranquility Lodge 2000 is physically based in Texas under the auspices of The Grand Lodge of Texas the Lodge’s charter relates, “

You can’t make this stuff up and I stand very humbly corrected. Whether Downard was aware of this, I don’t know. Probably, as the Masons made no secret that many astronauts were Masons in Space. Among others, L. Gordon Cooper, Jr.; Donn F. Eisle; Walter M. Schirra; Thomas P. Stafford; Edgar D. Mitchell, and Paul J. Weitz were all astronaut-Masons. The astronaut who died in a flash fire at Cape Kennedy on January 27, 1967, Virgil I. “Gus” Grissom, was a Mason, too.

Nor was Aldrin’s the first Freemason flag in outer space. Gordon Cooper, during his Gemini V spaceflight in August of 1965, carried with him an official Thirty-third Degree Jewel and a Scottish Rite flag.

Why was none of this mentioned in “°I’d speculate that — given the essay was reportedly an excerpt from a much longer, unpublished piece — that the prudent editors of “ decided to err on the side of non-libelous discretion when it came to associating names of still-living astronauts with a Gonzo theory of a plot to kill JFK in order to put Freemasonry on the Moon. Indicting George Washington, Ben Franklin, George Mason? Cool. Doing the same to Wally Schirra, Gordo Cooper, and Buzz Aldrin? Not so cool. That may also be why “°was replaced in later printings of “by different essay fromJames Shelby Downard.

Now back to the dialogue between the Callow Youth of America and the Wise Old Owl.

The Place Where Faith, Hope, and Charity Died

WOO: There’s all sorts of parallel references between “°and“Murder Most Foul” outside of ritual king slaying. For example, both focus on the reoccurrence of the number three in various permutations, including the triple overpass, Trinity River and the “three bums” featured in the song.

writes Downard.

Again, not quite accurate, but correcting Downard and following the three tramps/bums/hoboes story any further will lead us down another conspiracy rabbit hole. If you’re interested, try Googling “three tramps.” I will note before our leaving the trio that none of its members were E. Howard Hunt nor Woody Harrelson’s Dad, conspiracy claims to the contrary.

writesDownard. “

recites the narrator of “Murder Most Foul.” Although surprisingly not mentioned by Downard, the man who shot the film, Abraham Zapruder, was allegedly a Freemason and an Inspector-General (33rd degree) of the Scottish Rite.

And the 33rd line of “Murder Most Foul” as published on could be interpreted as a reference to Freemasonry…

Had enough? Maybe one more. writes Downard,

relates “Murder Most Foul’s” narrator.

After several hundred words of insanity, to be followed by several hundred words more, Downard interrupts himself with his most rational paragraph of °.


or call it…

~ “Murder Most Foul”

CYA: Wow. Just, wow. This is very weird.

WOO: No kidding. Dylan seems to have a bent towards Freemasonry and Masonic symbology. He mentioned Masons more than once on his “Theme Time Radio Hour” radio show…

Image for post
Image for post
The “Masonic Eye”?

… and there’s been speculation among fans that the stage backdrop that he occasionally uses in concert is based on Masonic imagery (others claim it more resembles the Egyptian “Eye of Horus”). And to add to the weirdness, for a time Dylan was closing some of his concerts by making a strange gesture that looked a lot like the Mason’s “Grand Hailing Sign of Distress.”

CYA: Okay, mind officially blown. But can we get back to the song without talking about Masons?

WOO: Sure. Sorry for the digression. Where do you want to go?

CYA: Why all the Boomer songs? More buttons being pushed?

WOO: Sure, there’s a bit of that going on. But there’s a lot of songs alluded to in “Murder Most Foul” that are way before and way after Boomer times. Charlie Poole’s “White House Blues” — another song about a presidential assassination — was recorded in 1926, for instance. Eminem’s “Darkness” was released January of 2020.

CYA: Dylan likes Eminem?

Image for post
Image for post
“Music to be Murdered By” By Source, Fair use

WOO: Maybe. Lots of speculation about that one in the Dylan fan community. If you buy into the idea that Dylan is referring to Eminem’s “Darkness” in the third to last line of “Murder Most Foul” —then that means Dylan recorded the song sometime after January of this year, an idea some fans have difficulty with for various reasons. Eminem’s “Darkness” fits for a lot of Dylanesque reasons — it’s from an album called “Music to be Murdered By” and is about the Las Vegas sniper killings of 2017 — but other possible candidates range from Leonard Cohen’s “Darkness” to Simon and Garfunkel’s “The Sounds of Silence”

It’s one of the great things about “Murder Most Foul.” It could be referencing any of those songs, or some other song I don’t even know about. Or it could be referencing those songs. You don’t have to pick one to the exclusion of all others.

CYA: Any other cool song references?

WOO: There’s a ton — too many to list here. I did a Spotify playlist of song / musician references in “Murder Most Foul” and ended up with 90+ songs, although a few of my choices are a stretch. Some of the references are obvious wordplays on Kennedy or the assassination — “New Frontier,” “Only the Good Die Young,” “Another One Bites the Dust” — others seem to be there because Dylan likes the song or the artist — Warren Zevon’s “Desperados Under The Eaves,” Julie London’s “Cry Me A River,” Isaac Bitton’s (aka Raya Mehmena) ”In G-D We Trust”. It’s like a “Theme Time Radio Hour” playlist, although several of Dylan’s choices are downright weird.

CYA: I bet my “weird” isn’t your “weird.”

WOO: I wouldn’t take that bet. I mean, what the hell are two songs from “Tommy” doing in “Murder Most Foul”? The Who’s bombastic “rock opera” is like the antithesis of everything Dylan was doing in 1969. Are they supposed to be references to being deaf, blind and dumb? To Woodstock? To LSD? To CIA mind-control?

CYA: Okay, Boomer, calm down. LSD and CIA mind-control?

WOO: Yeah, go Google MKULTRA. And, there’s a common thread in JFK assassination conspiracy theories that Oswald was being telepathically mind-controlled by some entity — the CIA being the most popular suspect. Downard brings up the theory in °.

CYA: No more Masons!

Image for post
Image for post
36 Hours

WOO: Sorry. CIA mind-control might explain two of “Murder Most Foul’s” more opaque Onewhere the narrator calls in a request to Wolfman Jack for Etta James’ “I’d Rather Go Blind,” dedicating it to “that man being Lee Oswald.

On the other hand, the line might not have anything to do with mind control and could be a reference to the Amazing Criswell, who reputedly predicted that JFK would not run for re-election

CYA: That one seems a stretch.

WOO: I don’t disagree, and just throw the idea out there because Dylan mentioned Criswell on an episode of “Theme Time Radio Hour,” in the same breath as Madame Blavatsky, founder of the Theosophical Society and Edgar Cayce, the spiritual healer.

Dylan is reportedly a reader and fan of both Cayce and Blavatsky, and in fact uses the latter’s writings as a source multiple times in , according to researcher Scott Warmuth. I suspect that if someone did a close comparison between Cayce’s writings and Dylan’s memoir, the same would hold true for the former. I’ll concede the Amazing Criswell is a dubious addition, but I’d like to think that the old, outrageous fakir holds a special place in Dylan’s heart, given his liking for performers who make a living from duping their audience while entertaining at the same time.

Anyway, the other mind-control reference is the line noting that “

CYA: What’s that one got to do with mind control?

WOO: It’s so specific. Why “thirty-six hours”?

Bob Dylan is a film fanatic. He’s made references to specific movies in his songs throughout his career. “Murder Most Foul” is no exception —”Gone with the Wind,” “What’s New Pussycat?” “Nightmare on Elm Street,” a film noir called “Ride the Pink Horse,” “All That Jazz,” “The Birdman of Alcatraz,” “It Happened One Night,” “One Night of Sin,” “Play Misty for Me” — and maybe an obscure film from 1965 about Nazi mind control that has the tag line, “Give me any American for 36 hours and I’ll give you back a traitor.”

CYA: Hmm. I gotta go soon. I know you’re not big on interpreting what Dylan is trying to say, but what do think “Murder Most Foul” is about?

Image for post
Image for post

WOO: I keep changing my mind, and will probably change it again, maybe before I even finish this article.

Any honest interpretation of “Murder Most Foul” is a worthwhile interpretation. There’s a very good article arguing that the song is a polemic; Dylan’s attack on the Boomer generation for being lulled into submission by drugs, sex and wild, wild music during the ‘60s, rather than fighting the forces that killed Kennedy and were / are controlling them. I don’t buy it — I don’t think Bob Dylan gives a damn about Boomers — but as I said, it’s a worthy interpretation and worth reading.

Me, I think his intent — let me emphasize “might” — be traced back to the two documents which seem to be Dylan’s primary sources for “Murder Most Foul” — “°anda pamphlet that shares the song’s title, Stanley J. Marks’ “As Dylan took several conspiracy theories from°,it appearshe also borrowed both ideas and lines from Marks’ pamphlet, including Kennedy being “shot down like a dog.”

I haven’t read Mark’s 1967 pamphlet, although I’ve read others of his many works. Marks seems to have had a fertile career, writing other pieces on the Kennedy assassination as well as on the “downfall of Christianity,” and conspiracies fostered by the Reagan / Bush administrations until he and his “Bureau of International Affairs” publishing house fell silent in the ’90s. For a conspiracy theorist, Marks often seems downright rational, although, like most conspiracy theorists, he’ll ignore facts that don’t fit into his theories.

James Shelby Downard, on the other hand, is a full-tilt bull goose loonie, happily careening from idea to idea, conspiracy to conspiracy, in “°like a pinball soaked in meth.

Image for post
Image for post
via The Onion

Here’s where I wander into trouble, trying to interpret what Bob Dylan is thinking: but as much as he seemed intrigued by the idea that Kennedy was a victim of a conspiracy in the 1960s, as much as he reportedly dabbled in occultism in the ’70s, I find it hard to believe that the Bob Dylan of 2020 could think of either Marks’ “ or Downard’s “°as anything but trash — maybe entertaining trash, but still trash.

Decade after decade, every Kennedy conspiracy theory has been shot down as forensics improved. No magic bullet, no series of shots recorded by a police motorcyclist. No nothing but a punk who wanted the world to know who he was, and got lucky with one shot.

Image for post
Image for post
Jesus in a piece of toast

Man is a creature programmed by Nature to recognize patterns. It’s what saved our asses when we first came down from the trees. The downside of hard-wired pattern recognition is that Man sees patterns everywhere, whether they’re real or not.

It’s why we see clouds that look like dragons, find Jesus in a piece of toast, believe in conspiracy theories.

Maybe what Dylan is trying to get across is exactly the opposite of what the narrator of “Murder Most Foul” is telling us. Sometimes there are no patterns, sometimes there are no conspiracies, and in an era of Fake News and politicians lying through their teeth, maybe it’s just the random world and Death will come when it comes. Maybe it’s better to observe the world and decide the truth for yourself.


Callow Youth of America: Okay, wow. One last thing: isn’t a “wise old owl” not supposed to speak much?

Wise Old Owl: Shut your mouth.

Written by

Corporate Storyteller. Tech enthusiast. Mini Cooper fanboy. One-time chronicler of Bob Dylan’s Theme Time Radio Hour. Husband of Peggy. Human of Lily Rose.

Get the Medium app

A button that says 'Download on the App Store', and if clicked it will lead you to the iOS App store
A button that says 'Get it on, Google Play', and if clicked it will lead you to the Google Play store